Hydrology and Home Insurance: Widespread Flooding after Storm Callum

Storm Callum has recently caused rivers in Wales to burst from their banks and flood nearly 200 homes. As a result, Operations Manager Huwel Manley of Natural Resources Wales (NRW) said, “There will be a large review about the flooding issues and flood protection.” First Minister Carwyn Jones said NRW's review will decide whether "there needs to be a rejigging of priorities in terms of where the work is done in the future".

The clean-up and reinstatement process may take months or even years for some, however the review may provide some reassurance for people and businesses whose properties have suffered damage. Thankfully for property owners, the costs will be covered by insurance, for those that have it. Although not on the same scale as Storm Desmond in December 2015, the damage caused by Storm Callum is likely to cost the insurance industry millions of pounds. Unfortunately, the possibility of recovery isn’t always open to insurers if the event was a true ‘natural disaster.’ However, insurers and their representatives should bear in mind that there may be a possibility of third party liability for the damage if someone’s action--or inaction-- caused or contributed to the flooding.

“In widespread flooding events,” says hydrologist Richard Keightley of Hawkins’ London Office, “there can be a perception that flooding was a ‘natural disaster’, and that there is no prospect of recovery.” Richard has, however, investigated many flooding incidents which simply cannot be blamed on nature alone, including:

  • Accidental ‘filling in’ of a surface water drainage ditch;
  • Culverting a previously ‘open’ watercourse;
  • Poor design or failure of property flood defences (such as flood-proof doors);
  • A lack of maintenance of infrastructure;
  • Blockages;
  • Inadequate operation of, or failure of, infrastructure such as sluices and pumps;
  • Failure of flood defences;
  • Inappropriate development (such as development in the floodplain)

During investigations of flooding events, Richard has been able to show whether or not the rainfall was severe enough that flooding would have still occurred, irrespective of any alleged action or inaction. Hydrologists analyse rainfall and other data to work out the ‘Average Recurrence Interval’ (ARI), or return period, of an event.

The distribution of rainfall over time varies between individual events, and weather systems that cause persistent rainfall over a long duration rarely produce high intensity, short duration rainfall. Therefore a single storm will often have a different ARI depending on the duration that is considered. Small urban catchments are typically susceptible to flooding from short duration events, while large river catchments are typically susceptible to flooding from long duration events. A depth duration frequency model, such as that shown in the example below, is used to determine the ARI of rainfall over a range of durations.

This model is for Abergorlech, which is located in the catchment of the Afon Tywi, in Wales. Preliminary data suggests that during Storm Callum, approximately 140mm of rain fell in 48 hours at Abergorlech. The DDF model shows that this has an ARI of approximately 100 years.

The rainfall has often stopped, and the floodwater already drained, by the time a forensic hydrologist reaches the scene. News and social media reports provide a valuable resource for information about the flood event. Computer modelling can also be used to replicate a flood, using LiDAR (Light Detection and Ranging, a type of aerial laser scanning) to recognise the topography of an area. This allows us to understand how floodwater would have travelled across the ground surface.

It is also worth noting, that the financial Ombudsman Service receives around 350 complaints about building insurance every month. Nearly half of complaints are regarding damage caused by weather events, such as flooding - with a marked increase in complaints following severe storms. 

After a flood, it can take years before a property becomes habitable again. Hawkins understands that investigating the root cause of damage due to a significant flood is an important step toward helping the community after a storm.

Please get in touch if you would like to enquire further about how a hydrologist can help in a flooding claim.

Latest News

Hong Kong Skuld P&I Casualty Seminar

20th Mar 2019

Recently Dr John Allum and Dr Sophie Parsons from Hawkins’ Hong Kong Office attended a Hong Kong Skuld P&I Casualty Seminar on the Investigation of Marine Claims. The presentation incorporated a discussion of materials failures by Dr Parsons, and ...

Read More

Hawkins Gives Back

19th Mar 2019

Hawkins recently sponsored a Masquerade Ball fundraising event on 3 March 2019 held by the Moor House School & College in Oxted, Surrey. Dr Simon Vallance attended with his wife, Jane Vallance, who is a Senior Teaching Assistant at the school. ...

Read More

A Poignant Moment for Hawkins

15th Mar 2019

In 1980, Roy Hawkins rented a single starter unit on the Cambridge Science Park and RB Hawkins & Associates was founded. Roy was one of the first tenants on what was trumpeted as the first Science Park in the country. It was built on the north side ...

Read More

Hawkins Welcomes Digital Examiner Erin LeMaster

13th Mar 2019

Hawkins is pleased to announce the arrival of Digital Examiner Erin LeMaster, and her newly-offered Digital Forensics services. Please click here to visit our Digital Forensics Page, and read more about how Erin, together with other select ...

Read More

Civil Engineers Attend North Downs Insurance Institute Dinner

12th Mar 2019

Four members of the Hawkins Building, Civil & Structural Engineering team, Ian Major, Andy Ingle, and Andrew Reeves from Hawkins’ Reigate Office, as well as Bernard Travers from Hawkins’ London Office, attended the North Downs Insurance Institute’s ...

Read More

Contact Us

Submitting this contact form will enter your details into our contacts database and we will reply to your request as soon as possible. We will also retain your details so we may contact you from time to time. You can ask us to remove your details at any time. For details, see our Privacy Notice.